Autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. While this book is written from the perspective of an international lawyer, its focus is on individuals and groups rather than states, the traditional subjects and objects of international law. The author has acted as an advisor or delegate in several of the settlement processes noted below. And the success of selfdetermination is not solely economic as when mississippi choctaw plows the fruits of economic development into.
Pavkovic explores how national selfdetermination, in the form of creation of a new state through secession, could override the principles of majority rule and of equal rights, which are primary liberal principles. It states that people, based on respect for the principle of equal rights and fair equality of opportunity, have the right to freely choose their sovereignty and. African studies american studies ancient near east and egypt art history asian studies book history and cartography biblical studies classical studies education. Hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. In order to explain the importance of sovereignty and selfdetermination to young students, have them think back to lessons that focus on how biodiversity is good for the planet. Sovereignty, independence, selfdetermination 267 nations, mr anderson, addressed the general assembly al341pv 101, 5 12. Candidate university of oregon kathleen stricklandcohen, ph. In fact, the colonial context is what specifically comes to mind when the right to self determination is brought up and it is the colonial aspect of the right to self determination that is uncontested, for the right to self determination consists of many elements and it has several aspects. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination.
Like the svp, the prosovereignty parties framed their. The accommodation of conflicting rights philadelphia. The importance of sovereignty and selfdetermination. I deny selfdetermination entails an unconditional right to a sovereign state. The meaning of international law father robert araujo abstract this essay contends that popular sovereignty and the other rights enumerated in the uni. For most states, self determination is framed by decolonization and is applicable to indigenous peoples only in limited senses of self government within state structures. The accommodation of conflicting rights pennsylvania press 1990 36. In the recent years the nationstates are witnessing ethnic upsurge almost all over. According to the united nations, self determination is both a right of states to choose their own political and economic systems and a right of peoples to constitute themselves as a state. In most cases, the minority group is a minority which has felt disadvantaged and discriminated against. This research finds that recognition of, or references to, the right to selfdetermination of peoples are absent from eu law sources. The concepts are often depicted as conflicting and incompatible. These are important suggestions about how to use a flexible approach to sovereignty and the right to ethnic selfdetermination to create a just and ordered multinationstate system.
Introduction this chapter addresses the interrelationship between resource sovereignty, self determination and the right to development, as defined in the declara. This thesis examines selfdetermination as a human right, focusing on the central question whether international law allows for a right of external selfdetermination in the form of unilateral secession when the internal right of selfdetermination is breached. These concepts provide moral legitimacy to the struggles in the region, even to those that often become violent. European union to try to execute state shattering selfdetermination with the intent and expectation to be immediately accepted as a new individual member of the european union. Self determination is the right of a country to be independent, instead of being controlled by a foreign country, and to choose its own form of government. Understanding right to selfdetermination introduction. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. Of particular value were meetings on ethnicity and rights, at columbia university in june 1986. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and. Self determination is the cardinal right sought by indigenous peoples and in practice it may require states to accept divisible sovereignty.
The discourse on native autonomy suggests that selfdetermination is not fully realized through selfgovernance alone. An examination of the conceptual tools joshua castellino follow this and additional works at. In this context it may be pertinent to quote hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty and selfdetermination who maintains that neither sovereignty nor selfdetermination is an absolute right. It is argued that there is a right of unilateral secession. This thesis examines self determination as a human right, focusing on the central question whether international law allows for a right of external self determination in the form of unilateral secession when the internal right of self determination is breached. The accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law hannum, hurst on. While a sovereignty exercising state can be a totalitarian regime, it can also be a democratic one in which. There is a conflict between the principles of territorial integrity and self determination. Self determination theory sdt is a broad theory of human personality and motivation concerned with how the individual interacts with and depends on the social environment.
Define and discuss with the students the ideas of sovereignty and self determination. Native selfrule, tribal sovereignty is now under increasingly vigorous and effective 2 ferraro 1998. Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of self. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Article on the right to external self determination. The meaning and range of the principle of selfdetermination. The statist conception equates selfdetermination with the familiar idea of state autonomy. Issues like these were discussed in slaughter, annemarie, a liberal theory of international law 2000 94 american society of international law proceedings 240. Selfdetermination as a human right peace palace library. Chapter 1will also provide some sense ofthe past cases that have led to the current debate surrounding self determinationand kosovo.
European union integration and national selfdetermination. Selfdetermination theory sdt is a broad theory of human personality and motivation concerned with how the individual interacts with and depends on the social environment. They developed a theory of motivation which suggested that people tend to be driven by a need to grow and gain fulfillment. Reimagining sovereignty in international investment law volume 65 issue 4 edward guntrip. The themes discussed in the preceding chaptersnational unity and integrity, the right to selfdetermination, the human rights of minorities and indigenous peoples, sovereigntyhave been raised, often stridently, in each of the case studies which follow. Understood in these terms, selfdetermination is an enduring notion in international thought. Territorial integrity and the right to selfdetermination. Selfdetermination is defined as a right of nations to freely decide their sovereignty and political status without external compulsion or outside interference 2, p. China and the principle of selfdetermination of peoples columbia.
Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political sy. In order to explain the importance of sovereignty and self determination to young students, have them think back to lessons that focus on how biodiversity is good for the planet. Because nunavut has an inuit majority, it is considered one of canadas most advanced examples of aboriginal internal sovereignty. A territorial interpretation lea brilmayert the phrase selfdeterminationis simply loaded with dyna mite. There are scores of militant groups involved in armed upsurge using the latest and. In this section i track the history of colonisation in australian and indigenous affairs policy as it relates to the right to selfdetermination. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination detangles the relationship between a number of principles of international law and the exercise of sovereign power. Selfdetermination versus majority ruleequal rights. The principle of selfdetermination imposes a negative duty on states to refrain from interference in one anothers affairs. This article is brought to you for free and open access by the law journals at brooklynworks. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession united states institute of peace. Conceptualising selfdetermination and secession selfdetermination is a notion of political rights that can be traced back to ancient greece and rome.
Self determination is the right of a nation or people, which have a separate and distinct identity. Selfdetermination, occupation and the authority to. The focus of the european project, in direct contrast to the glorification of nationhood, is on consensual decisionmaking rather than sovereignty, making selfdetermination obsolete in a reality of eu integration. Territorial integrity refers to the protection of an independent states territory from aggression of other states. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum. Ryan university of rochester selfdetermination theory sdt is an empirically based theory of human motivation, development, and wellness. State, sovereignty, and selfdetermination liechtenstein. The right to selfdetermination has become one of the most complex issues for u. Steve cadue is tribal chairman of the kickapoo nation.
Director of the centre for international security and european studies cesice. History of selfdetermination selfdetermination in international law is the legal right for a people14 to attain a certain degree of autonomy from its sovereign. I therefore remain agnostic here as to whether secession is the best means of. The views expressed are strictly his own and are not attributable to any government or organization. Territorial integrity and the right to self determination. Indigenous selfdetermination and the legitimacy of sovereign. The theory focuses on types, rather than just amount, of motivation, paying particular. Selfdetermination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic.
Pdf the world over, agitations for selfdetermination, whether internal or external. Fordham international law journal volume 24, issue 5 2000 article 1 sovereignty, human rights, and. The project on state, sovereignty, and selfdetermination addresses issues of boundaries, identity, variants of autonomy, governance, selfdetermination, selfdeterminations potential devolutive and stateshattering capabilities, and the emerging version of selfdetermination as defining ones own destiny. Selfdetermination is the right of a country to be independent, instead of being controlled by a foreign country, and to choose its own form of government. There is no objective concept that is universally applicable and yet it is of foundational importance to. Representations of a relationship dan sarooshi abstract the meaning of the concept of sovereignty is largely contingent upon the text in which it figures. Selfdetermination theory grew out of the work of psychologists edward deci and richard ryan, who first introduced their ideas in their 1985 book selfdetermination and intrinsic motivation in human behavior.
The accommodation of conflicting rights university of pennsylvania press 1989 26. Selfdetermination definition and meaning collins english. The second form of selfdetermination was 4 hannum 1990. Document resume ed 407 321 so 027 204 harris, will. A precondition of the struggle for selfdetermination typically involves a minority ethnic groups perception that its autonomy within the framework of a multinational stateor even its very existenceis endangered. Nosd government, and it is for this reason that outsiders are obliged not to interfere. This includes the question of how an unwanted state can be imposed upon a. State sovereignty selfdetermination, selfgovernance. Australias position on the question of decolonization is a clear one which has been demonstrated by our active role in the committee of 24 and the council for namibia, by our participation in debates on. Define and discuss with students the ideas of sovereignty and self determination. His latest publications include settling self determination conflicts 2007 with barbara metzger, and universal minority rights 2007.
India is no exception and the state of manipur in the indias northeast is one of the most volatile areas. Selfdetermination of peoples and sovereignty over natural. Self determination, the process by which a group of people form their own state and choose their own government. This document is best viewed in the latest version of acrobat reader. The second group of problems arises when the principle of national selfdetermination is used to justify the creation of new states. Aboriginal selfgovernment in nunavut alternatives north. The right of a people to selfdetermination is a cardinal principle in modern international law commonly regarded as a jus cogens rule, binding, as such, on the united nations as authoritative interpretation of the charters norms. The tension between national sovereignty and selfdetermination has always been at the heart of democratic principles, but both cannot be found within the same borders.
Jane hofbauers assessment is conducted through an analysis of the different tiers of selfdetermination, ranging from the right to exercise external selfdetermination, the right to exercise forms of autonomy as a. Nonetheless, it was during the french revolution that self determination was declared to be a right of nations to statehood and sovereignty. A macrotheory of human motivation, development, and health edward l. Selfdetermination has been defined as the right to be recognized as an autonomous nation with international status free from paternalistic intervention by a settler state. By using this service, you agree that you will only keep articles for personal use, and will not. Self determination, however, is enshrined in key human rights documents and by. Self determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and wellbeing richard m. The right to selfdetermination and international law nzlii. Aboriginal selfdetermination is increasingly viewed as a way for aboriginal people to assert their collective identity and improve their socioeconomic and cultural status. Distinct from sovereignty, selfdetermination in this local context reflected ideas of collective participation, cultural distinctiveness, selfgovernance, free choice and freedom from discrimination.
Legal theory law of states, law of peoples penn law. It discusses chinas perception of selfdetermination elsewhere, including the. Self determination theory grew out of the work of psychologists edward deci and richard ryan, who first introduced their ideas in their 1985 book self determination and intrinsic motivation in human behavior. Department of state s policy planning staff selfdetermination sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession. Sovereignty and self determination are central features of international relations and international law. Intervention and collective selfdetermination jeff mcmahan. Selfdetermination can be defined as a the act or power of making ones own decisions and determining ones own political status. The self determination principle which advocates for countries to freely determine their international politics status and sovereignty without outside interference challenges the territorial integrity principle. In an exclusive setting, highlevel independent academic experts and practitioners from europe, the united states, and asia discussed the concept of autonomy, as opposed to fullfledged independence, as a. Article 22 relating to mandates was a partial recognition of the principle of self determination. Deci university of rochester human beings can be proactive and engaged or, alterna tively, passive and alienated, largely as a function of the. Reducing the right of selfdetermination to a right to autonomy is not in accordance with the idea of selfdetermination as a human right and neither is the denial of the right of secession in absoluto. Selfdetermination the notion of collective selfdetermination is as elusive as the notion of intervention and is variously understood in the literature. Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given.
Cosmopolitan sovereignty is the law of peoples because it places at its center. Discussions about self determination and secession have become active in recent years, especially in view of the many cases of resolving ethnic conflicts that erupted after the cold war that have impacted on the way to think about self determination. Issn online 23498846 sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of selfdetermination balraj puri vol. Independence has always been potentially destabilizing. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as a tool of peace many nationalist struggles and ethnic conflicts in northeast india have been rooted in the assertion of the idea of autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty. In each of the nine situations, autonomy, selfgovernment, or selfdetermination is demanded by a group within an existing state, in order to protect the groups culture. Can autonomy fulfil the right to selfdetermination. Selfdetermination of indigenous peoples within the human. Define and discuss with the students the ideas of sovereignty and selfdetermination.
Self determination of peoples and sovereignty over natural wealth and resources nicolaas schrijver in no case may a people be deprived of its means of subsistence. The right to selfdetermination is a fundamental tenet of international law, influencing relationships between states and amongst the subunits. On this view, the right of collective selfdetermination is the right to. Upon reaching an adequate understanding ofthe terms and precedents sufficient. It has been accepted for inclusion in brooklyn journal of. Consequently, what the zapatistas prove through their resistance i. Sovereignty, statehood, selfdetermination, and the issue of. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to. Sovereignty, selfdetermination, and human rights from. Department of state s policy planning staff selfdetermination sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession patricia carley united states institute of peace.
1414 284 532 814 753 1083 22 1302 752 251 223 588 546 203 1242 276 282 1023 214 1495 1101 148 1306 781 1320 1186 231 566 863 578 960